Everyday in our shop, we offer the world's largest selection of freshly ground nut butters and regionally made craft jams, jellies, and fruit butter spreads.  If you can't make it to us, you can still  have our products delivered right to your door.

Nut Butters


16 oz Preserves


Raspberry Scented Candle


PBJD T-Shirts


Join our mailing list to receive news, updates, and special offers.

Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli  

6125 W. Greenfield Ave.  West Allis, WI. 53214

Tel: 414-897-7987  E-mail: info@thepbjdeli.com

  • Facebook Classic
  • Twitter Classic
  • Grey Instagram Icon


Mon - Closed

Tues - Sunday  10am - 3pm